Skip to main content
Search Liberal.ca

Opinion editorial on the Temporary Foreign Worker Program

Posted on July 29, 2014

Mayor Naheed Nenshi should be applauded for his recent comments about Canada’s Temporary Foreign Worker Program. He not only pointed out that the federal Conservative government’s recent changes to the program will not work for our city, but that it is profoundly un-Canadian “[t]o treat people like commodities that come here for two years and serve us our coffee in the mornings.”

The government created major problems for the Temporary Foreign Worker Program when it began to loosen the rules in 2006; it created an approval process with little oversight that largely amounted to rubber stamping applications, which has directly led to Canadians losing their jobs to temporary foreign workers.

But the government’s most recent attempt to fix the very problems it created is a sledgehammer approach that will not work everywhere; the Temporary Foreign Worker Program has now become one of the federal government’s most anti-Alberta policies in decades. The new rules appear to be based on the assumption that every region and industry in Canada faces identical labour challenges.

Even in our respective ridings of Calgary Confederation and Calgary Skyview, which we hope to represent, have vastly different needs and characteristics. The lack of nuance in this government’s hap-hazard decision-making does not recognise the varying economic challenges in our communities.

More important than fixing the short term labour problem, however, is planning for the long term; not only because it is the right thing to do, but because as Mayor Nenshi correctly stated: “We need immigration in order for our system to work.”

Consider that in 1991 the Calgary Herald ran an editorial entitled, “Baby Boomers: Old age will force changes on society,” which pointed out that by 2030, one-fifth of our population will be over the age of 65. It concluded by stating: “There is no reversing the aging process, but with proper care Canada can grow old gracefully.” Twenty three years later, Statistics Canada now estimates that by 2030 almost one-quarter of our population will be over the age of 65.

Canada must seize the moment and meet the coming economic challenges head-on. The Temporary Foreign Worker Program brings people to Canada, most of who have proven that they can successfully integrate into Canadian society and our labour market. Unfortunately, it is also a system that brings people here for a limited time, only to send them back where they came from. If their employer cannot find a Canadian to fill their vacated position, they then hire a new Temporary Foreign Worker who has likely never been to Canada before.

Of course, not every temporary foreign worker aspires to become a Canadian citizen. But by creating new pathways to citizenship, we can give those who do, and who have a proven track record of economic success in this country, a fair chance to stay and continue to contribute to Canadian society. If Canada is prepared to welcome these individuals as temporary foreign workers, they deserve a fair and reasonable opportunity to become citizens.

Matt Grant
Liberal Candidate for Calgary Confederation

Darshan Kang
MLA for Calgary-McCall
Liberal Candidate for Calgary Skyview

Are these the kind of officials we want in government?

Posted on July 17, 2014

Canadians’ faith in public office holders and politics has been seriously shaken. We deserve answers to the questions that the Prime Minister has refused to answer.

Shareable_Duffy-charges_EN

Scenes from the road: June 28 – July 4

Posted on July 7, 2014

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace visit the Calgary Stampede grounds. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace visit the Calgary Stampede grounds. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace attend a pancake breakfast at the 2014 Calgary Stampede and meet Elizabeth May. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace attend a pancake breakfast at the 2014 Calgary Stampede and meet Elizabeth May. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace meet Mayor Nenshi at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace meet Mayor Nenshi at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau meets William Shatner at the start of the 2014 Calgary Stampede parade. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau meets William Shatner at the start of the 2014 Calgary Stampede parade. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace meet the Prime Minister at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace meet the Prime Minister at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace watch the opening parade at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau, Xavier, and Ella-Grace watch the opening parade at the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau at the opening parade of the 2014 Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Xavier and Ella-Grace try to get their hats back. July 4, 2014.Xavier and Ella-Grace try to get their hats back. July 4, 2014.

Justin Trudeau meets supporters during the Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.Justin Trudeau meets supporters during the Calgary Stampede. July 4, 2014.

Continue Reading ▾

Lac-Mégantic: One Year Later

Posted on July 7, 2014

I drove down to Lac-Mégantic on Sunday to join the thousands commemorating the tragic loss of life that occurred one year ago when a train, laden […]

A journey through the Arctic

Posted on July 5, 2014

Climate change is one of the great challenges of our time; it is a global issue, and the consequences are both visible and invisible to the eye.

Scenes from the road: June 21 – 27

Posted on July 2, 2014

Justin Trudeau and Kyle Harrietha, Liberal candidate for Fort McMurray—Athabasca, meet constituents. June 25, 2014. Justin Trudeau and Kyle Harrietha, Liberal candidate for Fort McMurray—Athabasca, meet […]

A fantastic night for Liberals!

Posted on July 2, 2014 | No Comments

From coast to coast, city to suburbs, only ONE party increased its support from Canadians in every single by-election.

Happy Canada Day to all — from coast to coast to coast!

Posted by Justin Trudeau on July 1, 2014 | No Comments

Today is an incredibly great day to be Canadian
Let’s celebrate a country that embraces the fact that our differences have become our greatest strength — a country where we have come together to build prosperous engaging communities in mutual respect and cooperation

Congratulate our by-election candidates — add your name!

Posted on July 1, 2014 | No Comments

Take a moment to thank Adam, Arnold, Kyle and Dustin for their extraordinary efforts!

Carolyn Bennett on WorldPride

Posted on June 29, 2014 | No Comments

I’ve attended Pride celebrations in Toronto for the past 20 years and it seems to me that they just keep getting better and better. Toronto hosted […]